The rap made its first appearance in Season 1 Episode 2, resulting in this freestyle rap which showed off their skills and Spanish words that don’t make sense but somehow rhyme perfectly, making it wonderfully zany and beautiful. It’s the perfect example of their friendship. Troy and Abed often conspicuously act as if they break the fourth wall (of "Troy & Abed in the Morning" but not of Community) by discussing and gesturing towards the fictitious camera and production crew for their morning show, who are not actually present in the study room. Others often play along, acting as guests or studio audience members for the clearly imaginary show (which is, ironically, actually being filmed in a studio as part of Community). The fifth appearance again takes place in Troy and Abed's apartment but this time it's a special nighttime edition. Coinciding with the theme of the show, they are dressed in pajamas and are holding wine glasses instead of coffee mugs. Sitting in their recliners, they proceed to take phone calls from viewers, the first of which happens to be an annoyed Jeff who they have called at 3 in the morning. The second call they take is from Annie who is phoning them from her bedroom located right next to their studio. She yells at them to be quiet and the two hosts take the hint and sign off in singsong with their modified show name.

In the study room, Troy and Abed are again doing their morning show, this time joined by Dr. Rich. He is discussing his infamous kettle corn and reveals that his secret ingredient is a couple extra pinches of love. Jeff enters the study room aggravated that that duo are at it again with their fake talk show. Rich says even though the show is fake, he feels it's a fun way to start the day and asks Jeff to join them. After Jeff storms off, Rich chimes in with Troy and Abed to singsong the show's name. Annie decides to put on her own version of the show on in the study room with her as a co-host and her stuffed animals filling in for Troy and Abed. The real Troy and Abed then walk in and are angered when they see what she is doing. Annie joins her new roommates in the fourth appearance of the show, which is now located in the trio's apartment. She gives design tips to spruce up one's home on a budget. After a few small examples, she reveals she did an extensive makeover of Troy and Abed's bedroom. Abed doesn't take the changes well and starts to have a meltdown, forcing Troy to put the show on hold citing technical difficulties. Their rap skills even make a reappearance when Betty White guest starred, this time taking away the Spanish part and turning it into a rap about Anthropology – which again, makes no sense, but who can deny their perfect chemistry and wonderful beats?Several different versions of Troy and Abed's signature sign-off have been said on the show using the same intonation and singsong manner: A " Darkest Timeline" version of the "Troy and Abed in the Morning" show is shown with Evil Troy and Evil Abed. Featuring appearances from Evil Ben Chang, Timeline Five's Troy and Britta and Evil Jeff.

Troy and Abed are again in Group Study Room F joined by Alex "Star-Burns" Osbourne who is holding a turtle. They inquire about the turtle's diet, but Star-burns doesn't know as he had just been grabbed outside the study room, given the turtle and asked to smile for the "cameras". Laughing off his confusion, Troy and Abed turn to their weatherman Garrett for a report on the days forecast. He declares it's still sunny.